The Writers Tree vs. Reedsy

Navigating the self-publishing world can be overwhelming, with countless platforms offering services to help authors bring their books to life. Among these options, The Writers Tree and Reedsy stand out as two prominent choices for authors seeking professional assistance. While The Writers Tree provides a comprehensive suite of end-to-end publishing services, Reedsy operates as a dynamic marketplace connecting authors with a curated network of freelance experts.

This article offers a detailed comparison of these two platforms, examining their services, pricing, royalties, publishing timelines, marketing support, print-on-demand (POD) options, and customer reviews. Whether you’re a first-time author or a seasoned writer, understanding the differences between The Writers Tree and Reedsy will help you determine which platform best suits your publishing goals. Dive in to explore the pros, cons, and key insights that can shape your publishing journey.

Key Differences Between The Writers Tree and Reedsy

While both The Writers Tree and Reedsy cater to self-publishing authors, their approaches, pricing models, and support structures differ significantly. Here are the three main distinctions:

1. Service Model: The Writers Tree offers an all-in-one solution, handling every aspect of the publishing process under one roof. From ghostwriting and editing to marketing and distribution, their services are designed for authors who prefer a hands-off approach. Reedsy, in contrast, is a freelancer marketplace. Authors have the flexibility to handpick and hire individual professionals for specific tasks like editing, design, or marketing, but they must manage these collaborators independently.
2. Pricing and Costs: The Writers Tree emphasizes affordability with flexible, project-based pricing that bundles services together. While costs can vary, it caters to authors with limited budgets. Reedsy charges higher overall costs, including freelancer fees, a platform fee (up to 10%), and a payment processing fee (2.9%). These expenses make it better suited for authors with larger budgets.
3. Support and Guidance: The Writers Tree provides moderate support, making it accessible for first-time authors who need guidance through the publishing process. Reedsy offers minimal support, as authors are responsible for coordinating with freelancers and managing projects independently. It’s more suitable for experienced authors who are confident in self-publishing management.

These distinctions highlight the contrasting philosophies of The Writers Tree and Reedsy, giving authors clear options based on their budget, experience, and preferred level of involvement.

FEATURE
⭐ Customer Experience	Mixed (4.1 on Sitejabber) with praise for professionalism but some upsell concerns.	Positive (4.6 on Trustpilot) for vetted professionals, but lacks centralized support.
💸 Affordability	Generally affordable with customizable project-based pricing.	High costs due to freelancer, platform, and payment fees.
💰Royalties	Not disclosed publicly.	Authors retain 100% of royalties.
⏳Production Speed	Flexible and efficient, timelines tailored to project complexity.	Freelancer-dependent, with varying delivery speeds.
🏢 Marketing Services	Included in packages (e.g., trailers, SEO, promotions).	Available separately; offered by freelancers at additional cost.
🌎 Distribution	Provides print-on-demand (POD) and global distribution.	Relies on Blurb for POD and distribution, adding complexity.
🧑‍💻 Support	Moderate support; mixed reviews highlight variability.	Minimal support; authors manage freelancers independently.
📚Formats	Offers multiple formats, including audiobooks.	Supports print, digital, and audiobook formats via hired professionals.
💎 Transparency	Pricing and royalties lack full transparency.	Transparent pricing for freelancers but no guarantees on quality.

Overview of The Writers Tree

The Writers Tree is a full-service publishing platform designed to support authors at every stage of their writing and publishing journey. Known for its comprehensive offerings, the company provides a wide range of services, including ghostwriting, editing, book marketing, audiobook production, and website development. With a mission to simplify the publishing process, The Writers Tree caters to both new and established authors, making professional publishing accessible and affordable.

What sets The Writers Tree apart is its versatility and end-to-end approach. Authors can rely on the platform for assistance with manuscript creation, design, promotion, and even print-on-demand (POD) and distribution, creating a one-stop solution for self-publishing needs. The company is particularly appealing to first-time authors or those on a budget, as it offers flexible, project-based pricing to suit diverse financial constraints.

However, The Writers Tree is not without its limitations. While it provides a broad spectrum of services, its lack of transparency around royalties and pricing can be a drawback for authors seeking clear financial expectations. Additionally, some customer reviews mention occasional upsells and variability in support quality, which may affect the overall experience. Despite these drawbacks, The Writers Tree remains a solid choice for authors seeking a budget-friendly, all-in-one publishing solution.

Key Features of The Writers Tree

• Comprehensive Publishing Services: Offers ghostwriting, editing, book marketing, audiobook production, and website development, covering every stage of the publishing process.
• Affordable Pricing Options: Provides flexible, project-based pricing tailored to individual author needs, making it accessible to authors with varying budgets.
• Marketing Support: Includes promotional tools like book trailers, SEO optimization, and online presence building to boost book visibility.
• Audiobook Production: Converts written works into audiobooks, catering to the growing demand for audio content.
• Print-On-Demand (POD) and Distribution: Facilitates book printing and global distribution, ensuring authors can reach wide audiences.
• Customized Book Design: Professional cover design and interior formatting services to create visually appealing and market-ready books.
• Author Website Development: Builds user-friendly, SEO-optimized websites to establish a strong online presence for authors.
• End-to-End Support: Aims to simplify the publishing journey by managing complex processes, ideal for first-time or less experienced authors.
• Positive Customer Feedback: Commended for professionalism and delivering quality work, with many clients returning for repeat projects.

The Writers Tree: What They Don’t Offer

• Royalty Transparency: Does not publicly disclose details about royalties, leaving authors unclear on potential earnings.
• Guaranteed Pricing Consistency: Pricing can vary significantly based on project complexity, with reports of unexpected upsells.
• Better Business Bureau (BBB) Accreditation: The company is not BBB accredited, which may raise concerns about accountability for some authors.
• Hands-On Author Control: Lacks the flexibility for authors to handpick individual professionals for specific tasks, unlike freelancer marketplaces.
• Dedicated Distribution Platform: While offering POD services, it does not provide a proprietary distribution platform or dashboard for authors to track sales.
• Extensive Customer Support: Mixed reviews on customer service suggest a lack of consistent, high-quality support for complex or challenging projects.
• Pre-Publishing Educational Resources: Does not offer in-depth self-publishing courses or educational content to guide new authors through the process.

Overview of Reedsy

Reedsy is a marketplace platform that connects authors with a curated network of publishing professionals, including editors, designers, marketers, ghostwriters, and web designers. Established in 2014, Reedsy is renowned for its rigorous vetting process, ensuring that the freelancers on its platform are skilled and experienced. This focus on quality has made Reedsy a popular choice for authors seeking top-tier professional assistance with their self-publishing projects.

What sets Reedsy apart is the control and flexibility it offers authors. Writers can handpick collaborators based on their expertise, pricing, and reviews, allowing for a highly customized publishing experience. Reedsy also provides unique tools, such as the free Reedsy Book Editor for formatting manuscripts and Reedsy Discovery, a platform designed to connect authors with book reviewers and build readership. This makes Reedsy ideal for experienced authors or those with a clear vision for their projects.

Top rated publishers:

Visit site

9.5

However, Reedsy has its limitations. It is not an all-in-one publishing platform, meaning authors must independently manage various aspects of the publishing process, such as distribution and sales. Additionally, the costs of hiring multiple freelancers can add up quickly, making it less accessible for authors on a tight budget. For new or inexperienced authors, the lack of centralized support can also be challenging, as navigating the self-publishing process requires a hands-on approach. Despite these drawbacks, Reedsy excels in delivering high-quality, customizable services for authors who prioritize control and professional expertise.\

Key Features of Reedsy

• Marketplace for Freelance Professionals: Connects authors with vetted experts for editing, design, marketing, ghostwriting, and web design.
• Customizable Collaboration: Allows authors to handpick professionals based on reviews, experience, and pricing, ensuring a tailored publishing experience.
• Reedsy Book Editor: A free online tool for writing, editing, and formatting manuscripts, simplifying the typesetting process.
• Reedsy Discovery: A platform that connects authors with book reviewers, helping build an audience and increase book visibility.
• High-Quality Professionals: A rigorous vetting process ensures that all freelancers on the platform have proven expertise in their respective fields.
• Educational Resources: Offers free courses and tools for authors, covering topics like self-publishing, book marketing, and Amazon algorithms.
• Flexible Services: Supports a wide range of projects, from developmental editing to custom illustrations and typography.
• Royalty Retention: Authors keep 100% of their royalties, as Reedsy does not take a share of book sales.
• Integration with Blurb for POD: Partners with Blurb to provide print-on-demand and distribution options for authors.
• Transparency in Hiring: Clearly displays freelancer profiles, pricing, and client reviews for informed decision-making.

Reedsy: What They Don’t Offer

• All-in-One Publishing Solution: Lacks comprehensive, bundled services; authors must manage each stage of publishing independently.
• Integrated Distribution: Does not offer direct book distribution services; relies on third-party providers like Blurb for print-on-demand (POD) and distribution.
• Centralized Support: Provides no overarching project management or customer service to guide authors through the process; authors are responsible for coordinating freelancers.
• First-Time Author Accessibility: Lack of hands-on support and guidance can make the platform challenging for inexperienced authors.
• Standardized Pricing: Authors must negotiate with freelancers individually, leading to potentially inconsistent pricing for services.

Comparing Affordability/Costs

When it comes to affordability, The Writers Tree stands out as the more budget-friendly option, particularly for authors seeking bundled services. Their flexible, project-based pricing allows authors to select only the services they need, making it accessible for those on tighter budgets. While pricing can vary based on project complexity, The Writers Tree’s emphasis on affordability makes it an attractive choice for cost-conscious authors.

Reedsy, on the other hand, operates as a premium marketplace. While accessing the platform is free, hiring freelancers comes with higher costs, including a 10% platform fee and a 2.9% payment processing fee. The à la carte nature of Reedsy’s services means that costs can quickly add up for authors requiring multiple services. While Reedsy provides access to highly skilled professionals, its pricing model is better suited for authors with larger budgets or those seeking top-tier expertise.

In summary, The Writers Tree is the more affordable option for authors looking for bundled services and manageable costs, while Reedsy appeals to those willing to invest in specialized, high-quality professionals.

Publishing Timelines

Publishing timelines differ significantly between The Writers Tree and Reedsy, reflecting their distinct service models.

The Writers Tree emphasizes efficient service delivery, with timelines tailored to the complexity of each project. While specific deadlines are not publicly disclosed, customer feedback suggests that they deliver projects promptly, with some clients even receiving completed work earlier than expected. This makes The Writers Tree a good option for authors who need a reliable and predictable publishing schedule.

Reedsy, by contrast, has timelines that vary widely depending on the freelancers an author hires. Since each professional sets their own schedule, authors must negotiate and manage deadlines individually. While this flexibility allows authors to work at their own pace, it can lead to longer timelines, particularly if multiple freelancers are involved or delays occur.

In summary, The Writers Tree offers a more streamlined and predictable timeline, making it ideal for authors who value speed and efficiency. Reedsy’s timelines are flexible but potentially longer, depending on the coordination between freelancers and the complexity of the project.

Top rated publishers:

Visit site

9.5

Royalties

The Writers Tree does not disclose details about its royalty structure publicly. Authors are advised to contact the company directly to clarify terms such as payout percentages, payment schedules, and conditions. This lack of transparency may concern authors who prioritize understanding their potential earnings and want clarity on royalty splits.

Reedsy, on the other hand, allows authors to retain 100% of their royalties. As Reedsy operates solely as a service marketplace, it does not involve itself in book sales or royalty collection. Authors are fully responsible for managing their distribution and sales channels, which means royalties are directly handled through platforms like Amazon or Blurb. While this approach ensures maximum earnings, it requires authors to independently navigate the complexities of sales and payouts.

In comparison:

• Reedsy clearly stands out in terms of royalty retention, offering authors complete control over their earnings.
• The Writers Tree’s lack of transparency may leave authors uncertain about how royalties are calculated and distributed.

For authors prioritizing maximum royalty retention and full control, Reedsy is the stronger choice. However, those seeking a more managed process may find The Writers Tree’s approach appealing, provided they confirm royalty details beforehand.

Marketing Services

The Writers Tree provides a range of marketing services designed to simplify the often challenging task of promoting a book. These services include creating book trailers, SEO-optimized website development, and building an online presence to enhance visibility. Marketing support is included in their publishing packages, which makes it more accessible for authors who prefer an all-in-one solution. While the cost of these services is folded into the overall project pricing, authors can request tailored packages to suit their specific needs. For first-time or inexperienced authors, The Writers Tree’s integrated marketing options can be a major advantage, offering convenience and reducing the effort required to self-promote.

Reedsy, in contrast, offers marketing as a standalone service through its freelancer marketplace. Authors can hire marketing professionals for tasks such as developing promotional strategies, email marketing campaigns, and book advertising. While this allows for a customized approach, the cost can be significant, as authors must pay each freelancer’s fees individually in addition to platform fees. Furthermore, Reedsy does not offer bundled marketing packages, meaning authors need to coordinate multiple freelancers for a comprehensive campaign.

In summary:

• The Writers Tree offers a more comprehensive and accessible marketing solution as part of their publishing packages, making it easier for authors to focus on their writing.
• Reedsy provides flexibility and access to high-caliber marketing professionals but may be costly and require more effort to manage.

For authors seeking hands-off support, The Writers Tree is a better choice, while experienced authors with a specific marketing vision may prefer the customization Reedsy offers.

POD & Distribution

The Writers Tree offers print-on-demand (POD) services and global distribution options as part of their publishing packages. These services ensure that authors can print physical copies of their books and distribute them to major retailers and online platforms, allowing their work to reach a broad audience. As the company focuses on providing end-to-end publishing support, POD and distribution are integrated into their offerings, making it easier for authors to manage these aspects without requiring external tools or platforms. This seamless integration is a strong feature for authors who want comprehensive publishing and distribution support in one place.

Reedsy, by contrast, does not directly handle POD or distribution. Instead, it partners with Blurb, a third-party POD and distribution provider. Through Blurb, authors can produce physical copies of their books and access distribution options to online retailers and global networks. However, this service is not included in Reedsy’s initial fees or packages and requires authors to independently manage their relationship with Blurb. While this partnership allows Reedsy to provide distribution options, the reliance on an external provider adds an extra layer of complexity for authors.

Comparison Summary:

• The Writers Tree excels in offering POD and distribution as an integrated part of their publishing services, streamlining the process for authors.
• Reedsy’s distribution service, through Blurb, is a useful addition but is not a primary focus of the platform and requires separate coordination by the author.

For authors looking for an all-in-one publishing and distribution solution, The Writers Tree is the stronger option. For those comfortable with external partnerships and prioritizing high-quality professionals, Reedsy’s Blurb collaboration provides flexibility but requires more effort.

Support Services

The Writers Tree offers moderate support for authors throughout the publishing process, aiming to make the experience smoother for clients. While they don’t assign dedicated publishing production managers, their team provides guidance during key stages, such as editing, marketing, and distribution. This makes The Writers Tree a suitable option for first-time or less experienced authors who might benefit from a structured approach. However, customer reviews indicate variability in the quality of support, with some clients praising the team’s responsiveness while others report challenges with communication or contract clarity.

Reedsy, on the other hand, provides minimal centralized support. As a freelancer marketplace, Reedsy does not assign project managers or oversee the publishing process. Authors are responsible for managing their own projects, coordinating with hired freelancers, and ensuring timelines and deliverables are met. While the platform is user-friendly, this hands-off approach may be daunting for first-time authors or those unfamiliar with the publishing process. Experienced authors who are confident in managing their projects may find independence appealing.

Comparison Summary:

• The Writers Tree provides a structured level of support, assisting authors through various stages of publishing, though the quality of support can vary.
• Reedsy offers little direct support, leaving authors to manage freelancers and navigate the process independently.

For authors seeking guidance or a more hands-off experience, The Writers Tree is a better fit. For experienced authors comfortable with self-management, Reedsy offers flexibility and control without additional oversight.

Customer Experience and Reviews

The Writers Tree has a mixed reputation among its customers, reflected in its 4.1-star rating on Sitejabber. Positive reviews frequently highlight the company’s professionalism, quality of work, and the ease of using its comprehensive services. Many authors, particularly first-time writers, appreciate the end-to-end support and affordable options, with some even returning for repeat projects. However, there are criticisms regarding contract clarity and occasional upselling, which some clients felt increased their costs unexpectedly. Others have noted inconsistencies in customer support, with experiences varying widely between users.

Reedsy enjoys a higher overall customer satisfaction, holding a 4.6-star rating on Trustpilot. Authors often praise the platform for its rigorous vetting of freelancers, providing access to skilled professionals with proven track records. The ability to customize projects and hire top-tier editors, designers, and marketers is a strong draw. However, some users have criticized the platform’s high costs and lack of centralized support, which can leave less experienced authors feeling overwhelmed. Despite these challenges, most reviews emphasize the quality of services received, making Reedsy a favorite for seasoned authors looking for premium publishing help.

Comparison Summary:

• The Writers Tree: 4.1-star rating; valued for affordability and comprehensive services but mixed reviews on support and pricing transparency.
• Reedsy: 4.6-star rating; celebrated for access to vetted professionals and customization but critiqued for high costs and limited support.

Both platforms cater to different needs, with The Writers Tree appealing to budget-conscious authors and Reedsy excelling for those seeking premium, customizable solutions.

The Writers Tree vs. Reedsy: Which is Right for You?

When deciding between The Writers Tree and Reedsy, authors should consider their experience level, publishing needs, and budget. For first-time authors, The Writers Tree is the better option. Its all-in-one service model provides structured support, helping new authors navigate the complexities of publishing without requiring them to manage multiple freelancers. In contrast, Reedsy’s freelancer marketplace can be overwhelming for beginners who may not yet have the skills or confidence to oversee their own publishing projects.

If customization and control are priorities, Reedsy is the ideal choice. It allows authors to handpick top-tier professionals for specific tasks, such as editing or marketing, offering unparalleled flexibility and access to expertise. However, this level of control comes at a cost—both in terms of higher prices and the effort required to manage freelancers effectively. Experienced authors who are comfortable navigating the self-publishing process will benefit most from Reedsy’s approach.

For marketing services, The Writers Tree provides a more convenient solution. Marketing is included in their publishing packages, offering accessible options like book trailers and online promotions. While Reedsy offers access to highly skilled marketing professionals, these services must be hired separately, adding costs and requiring authors to coordinate campaigns themselves.

Budget-conscious authors will also find The Writers Tree more appealing. Its flexible pricing structure makes it a cost-effective choice, particularly for those seeking bundled services. On the other hand, Reedsy’s platform fees and individual freelancer costs can quickly add up, making it better suited for authors with larger budgets.

For further details about services and pricing, readers can visit The Writers Tree or Reedsy on their respective websites.

Top rated publishers:

Visit site

9.5