- Jane Murphy
- 0 min read
Simon & Schuster vs. Scribe Media
Table of Contents
In the world of book publishing, authors often face the challenge of choosing between traditional publishing houses and more modern, self-publishing services. In this article, we will compare two prominent names in the industry: Simon & Schuster, one of the largest and most respected traditional publishers, and Scribe Media, a leading self-publishing service renowned for its high-quality, hands-on approach. Simon & Schuster offers established credibility, extensive distribution channels, and the resources that come with being a major publisher, while Scribe Media provides a more personalized experience, with a comprehensive suite of services for authors looking to retain full creative control and royalties. Each company has its unique strengths and caters to different types of authors, so whether you’re a seasoned professional or a first-time author, understanding the key differences will help you decide which path is best suited for your book. We’ll delve into their services, pricing, publishing timelines, and more to help you make an informed choice.
Key Differences
Publishing Model: Simon & Schuster is a traditional publisher that requires authors to go through a competitive submission process. Authors must secure a book deal, which often involves an agent, and only a small percentage of submissions are accepted. Simon & Schuster retains the rights to publish, distribute, and market the book, and authors typically receive an advance along with royalties from sales. Scribe Media, on the other hand, operates on a self-publishing model. Authors work directly with the Scribe team to turn their manuscripts into professionally published books. While authors retain full creative control and 100% of the royalties, they must pay upfront for Scribe’s services, which can range from editing and design to marketing and distribution.
Target Audience: Simon & Schuster is open to a wide range of genres, though it primarily focuses on popular commercial fiction, non-fiction, memoirs, and children’s books. As a traditional publisher, its focus is on books with broad market appeal and mass distribution. Scribe Media primarily targets non-fiction authors, especially those in business, self-help, and thought leadership. While Scribe does offer premium publishing services, its approach is particularly geared towards professionals like entrepreneurs, consultants, and executives who want to establish credibility through their published work.
Cost and Royalties: Simon & Schuster does not charge authors up front. Instead, authors receive a royalty percentage from book sales and may receive an advance against future royalties. The royalty rates typically range from 10% to 15% for print books and higher for digital formats. Scribe Media operates on a pay-to-publish model, where authors pay significant fees (ranging from $26,000 to $56,000) for professional services such as writing, editing, and marketing. However, authors retain 100% of the royalties from sales and maintain full control over the book’s distribution.
These differences make Simon & Schuster ideal for authors looking for traditional publishing with its established reach. Scribe Media appeals to those seeking a hands-on, professional self-publishing experience with full control and royalties.
| FEATURE |  |  |
| ⭐ Customer Experience | Personalized by literary agents and editors, but often less hands-on for authors. | Dedicated publishing managers for each author, providing full guidance. |
| 💸 Affordability | There are no upfront fees, but takes a cut of royalties and can require significant marketing investments. | High upfront costs (starting at $26,000), but no commission on royalties. |
| 💰Royalties | 10-15% of book sales, depending on the format and contract. | 100% of royalties remain with the author. |
| ⏳Production Speed | Can take over a year from submission to publication due to multiple stages of review and approval. | Takes 3-9 months, depending on the service package chosen. |
| 🏢 Marketing Services | Offers professional marketing and distribution, though typically limited to high-profile authors. | Comprehensive marketing services are included in premium packages. |
| 🌎 Distribution | Extensive, including global bookstores, major retailers, and wholesalers. | Broad distribution, including Amazon, IngramSpark, and major online retailers. |
| 🧑💻 Support | Authors receive support through agents and publishing teams, but it can be limited. | One-on-one support from a dedicated publishing manager throughout the process. |
| 📚Formats | Primarily focuses on hardcover, paperback, and eBook formats. | Offers eBook, paperback, hardcover, and audiobook production. |
| 💎 Transparency | Less transparent with internal processes and royalties. Authors may need to chase for updates. | Clear, upfront pricing and full transparency on services and royalties. |
Overview of Simon & Schuster
Simon & Schuster is one of the largest and most established traditional book publishers in the world. Founded in 1924, it has earned a reputation for producing best-selling books across a wide array of genres, including fiction, non-fiction, and children’s literature. Known for its extensive reach, Simon & Schuster offers authors the opportunity to work with industry professionals, such as literary agents, editors, and publicists, to refine their work and craft a marketable product. They excel in distribution and marketing, providing authors with access to major retail outlets, global bookstores, and a powerful network of media contacts.
Simon & Schuster primarily caters to established authors and those with a strong platform or recognition in the industry. It’s ideal for writers looking for a traditional publishing experience, including the potential for significant advances and wide-reaching publicity. However, the company is selective in its offerings, with a highly competitive submission process that requires a literary agent to approach them on an author’s behalf.
Where Simon & Schuster lacks is in its flexibility and transparency. The royalties offered are generally lower (typically 10-15%) compared to self-publishing platforms. Additionally, Simon & Schuster does not cater to self-published authors or those without literary representation. It also does not offer services such as ghostwriting, which might be necessary for authors who need significant assistance developing their manuscripts.
Key Features of Simon & Schuster
- Prestigious Reputation: A member of the “Big Five” publishing houses, offering authors credibility and industry recognition.
- Extensive Distribution Network: Access to global markets, major retailers, and online platforms for maximum visibility.
- Professional Editorial Support: High-quality editing and manuscript refinement by experienced editorial teams.
- Strong Marketing and Publicity: Tailored promotional strategies, including book tours, media appearances, and event planning for selected titles.
- No Upfront Costs: Simon & Schuster covers all production, design, and marketing expenses for authors under contract.
- Diverse Imprints: Specialized imprints such as Scribner, Atria Books, and Gallery Books cater to various genres and audiences.
- Advances Against Royalties: Authors may receive an advance, providing upfront financial support before book sales begin.
- Print, Digital, and Audio Formats: Books are produced across multiple formats to meet market demand.
- Rights and Licensing Opportunities: Authors can benefit from international publishing, translation rights, and multimedia adaptations.
- Long Publishing Timeline: The process, from submission to release, often spans 12-18 months.
What Simon & Schuster Does Not Offer
- Self-Publishing Services: Simon & Schuster does not cater to self-published authors or offer hybrid publishing options.
- Full Creative Control: Authors typically do not have full control over their book’s design, cover, or major editorial decisions.
- Complete Royalties Ownership: Authors do not retain 100% of royalties; the publisher takes a percentage of profits.
- Guaranteed Acceptance: As a traditional publisher, Simon & Schuster selects titles based on marketability, making it difficult for authors without significant industry connections or strong manuscripts.
- Exclusive Focus on Non-Fiction: While Simon & Schuster publishes both fiction and non-fiction, it is often known for prioritizing certain genres and well-known authors.
- Hands-Off Author Experience: Unlike some self-publishing platforms, Simon & Schuster demands active involvement in the marketing and publicity of a book.
Scribe Media Overview
Scribe Media, founded in 2014 by best-selling author Tucker Max, is a premium self-publishing service primarily designed for entrepreneurs, consultants, executives, and thought leaders looking to produce high-quality non-fiction books. Known for its hands-on, personalized approach, Scribe Media offers a comprehensive range of publishing services, including ghostwriting, editing, design, marketing, and distribution. The company is renowned for delivering polished, professional books with a focus on creating marketable works that align with an author’s brand and objectives.
Scribe’s unique selling point lies in its full-service model, where it offers 100% royalties to authors, comprehensive author support, and an experienced team of professionals, including writers, editors, and designers, who ensure each book reaches its highest potential. However, this premium service comes at a high price point, with costs starting around $26,000 and reaching up to $56,000 or more for more comprehensive packages.
Scribe Media does not cater to fiction writers and focuses exclusively on non-fiction works. Authors should also be prepared for longer publishing timelines, ranging from 6 to 9 months, which can be a drawback for those seeking faster results. While Scribe Media is an excellent choice for authors with the budget to invest in a top-tier publishing experience, it may not be suitable for those seeking lower-cost, DIY publishing options.
Scribe Media – Key Features
- Full-Service Publishing: Offers ghostwriting, editing, design, marketing, and distribution.
- Expert Team: Works with a team of experienced writers, editors, and designers, many of whom are best-selling authors.
- 100% Royalties: Authors retain full ownership of their royalties, maximizing profits from book sales.
- Premium, High-Quality Output: Known for producing professionally written, edited, and designed books that stand out in the market.
- Target Audience: Primarily caters to professionals, entrepreneurs, executives, and thought leaders with completed manuscripts.
- Long-Term Support: Provides dedicated publishing managers who guide authors through the entire process.
- Exclusive Non-Fiction Focus: Specializes in publishing non-fiction books, particularly those aimed at professionals and business-minded individuals.
- Marketing and Promotion: Offers strategic marketing plans, social media promotion, and targeted advertising to increase book visibility.
- Print-on-Demand & Distribution: Partners with major platforms like Amazon, IngramSpark, and Barnes & Noble for global distribution.
- Audiobook Creation: Option to turn books into audiobooks, narrated by professional voice actors.
- Comprehensive Packages: Multiple packages offering varying levels of service, from basic publishing to full-service ghostwriting and editorial support.
Scribe Media – Does Not Offer
- Fiction Publishing: Scribe Media exclusively focuses on non-fiction books, making it unsuitable for authors of fiction, poetry, or niche genres.
- Affordable Pricing: The cost of publishing with Scribe is on the high end, with services starting at $26,000, making it less accessible for authors with limited budgets.
- Automated or Low-Cost Self-Publishing: Unlike some other platforms, Scribe does not offer a simple, automated, or budget-friendly self-publishing option.
- Traditional Royalty Splits: While authors retain 100% of their royalties, there are distribution fees from third-party platforms like Amazon or IngramSpark that authors must account for.
- Open Submission for Manuscripts: Scribe Media primarily works with authors who have completed manuscripts, limiting their support for authors at earlier stages of the writing process.
- Global Rights Handling: While Scribe offers robust distribution, it may not support authors looking for more extensive international rights management or translation services.
Comparing Affordability: Simon & Schuster vs. Scribe Media
When it comes to pricing, Simon & Schuster and Scribe Media are at opposite ends of the spectrum, with significant differences in their affordability.
Simon & Schuster is a traditional publisher, meaning they do not charge authors upfront for publishing services. Instead, they offer authors an advance against royalties, which is paid once the book is accepted for publishing. This model is highly attractive to authors as there are no initial costs, but it is important to note that the publisher will retain control over various aspects of the book’s production and marketing. Authors with Simon & Schuster must also meet certain sales thresholds before receiving further royalties, and they usually face royalty splits of around 10% to 15% for print books, which is standard in traditional publishing.
In contrast, Scribe Media is a self-publishing service that operates on a premium pricing model. Their packages start at $26,000 for basic publishing services, with higher tiers reaching up to $56,000 or more for ghostwriting and more extensive support. While Scribe Media offers a fully managed, high-touch experience, this comes at a steep price. Authors with Scribe Media retain 100% of their royalties, which can be appealing, but the upfront cost is significantly higher compared to traditional publishing.
In terms of affordability, Simon & Schuster is the more budget-friendly option, especially for authors who prefer a traditional publishing route and do not want to pay upfront. Scribe Media, while offering premium services, is far more expensive, making it a better fit for authors with a larger budget looking for extensive professional support.
Publishing Timelines: Simon & Schuster vs. Scribe Media
The publishing timelines for Simon & Schuster and Scribe Media differ significantly, reflecting their respective business models and processes.
Simon & Schuster:
As a traditional publisher, Simon & Schuster typically operates on a longer timeline. The process from manuscript acceptance to publication can take anywhere from 12 to 24 months, depending on the complexity of the book, the publisher’s schedule, and other factors. After accepting a manuscript, the publisher will schedule the book’s release date, which is often strategically aligned with marketing campaigns, seasonal trends, or other major events. The process includes several stages—editing, cover design, printing, marketing, and distribution—all of which can contribute to a longer overall timeline. This timeline can feel lengthy to authors, but it reflects the thorough and often slower pace of traditional publishing.
Scribe Media:
In contrast, Scribe Media operates on a more expedited timeline. From manuscript submission to book launch, the process typically takes about 3 to 9 months. While the company provides comprehensive services such as editing, cover design, and marketing support, Scribe’s processes are highly structured and efficient, allowing for quicker turnaround times compared to traditional publishers. For eBooks, the process usually takes around 6 months, while print books might take 6 to 9 months, depending on the complexity of the project and the package chosen. This is a faster timeline, though some authors may feel the production time could still be long given the premium services involved.
Comparison:
- Simon & Schuster: 12–24 months, typical for traditional publishers.
- Scribe Media: 3–9 months, faster for self-publishing, but still extensive due to the high level of support provided.
In conclusion, Simon & Schuster offers a longer, more drawn-out timeline due to the nature of traditional publishing processes, while Scribe Media is faster, though its timeline still accounts for the detailed, hands-on services provided.
Royalties: Simon & Schuster vs. Scribe Media
When it comes to royalties, Simon & Schuster and Scribe Media have very different approaches, with significant implications for authors.
Simon & Schuster follows a traditional publishing model, offering authors a 10-15% royalty on the retail price of print books and 25% for eBook sales. This royalty percentage varies depending on the author’s contract and the sales channels. For established authors or those with strong sales, the percentage might increase slightly through tiered agreements. However, payments are processed on a quarterly basis, meaning authors receive royalties only four times a year. While this is standard in traditional publishing, it can be slower, especially when dealing with multiple distribution channels.
In contrast, Scribe Media provides authors with 100% of the royalties from their book sales. This is one of the major benefits of working with Scribe, as authors retain complete control over their earnings. Royalties are paid directly by the distributors, such as Amazon or Barnes & Noble, on a monthly basis, making the payout process faster and more transparent. Authors can track their royalties through their distributor’s platform (e.g., Amazon KDP), which allows for greater visibility and control.
Overall, Scribe Media’s approach is more author-friendly in terms of royalties. Authors receive all of their earnings, with quicker, monthly payouts, compared to Simon & Schuster’s slower, quarterly payments and lower royalty percentages. This makes Scribe Media a better option for authors who want to maximize their earnings and receive timely payments.
Marketing Services: Simon & Schuster vs. Scribe Media
Marketing is an essential part of the publishing process, and both Simon & Schuster and Scribe Media offer marketing services, though the scope and cost of these services differ significantly.
Simon & Schuster offers basic marketing support for authors, including public relations (PR) efforts, such as securing media placements, book reviews, and interviews, but it tends to focus more on established authors. For debut authors or less well-known writers, Simon & Schuster may not provide the same level of attention unless the book has strong market potential. The company may also offer support through book tours, social media promotion, and distribution to key retailers, but much of the marketing effort will fall on the author. Authors working with Simon & Schuster typically need to invest their own time and money into additional marketing efforts, such as advertising campaigns or outreach to influencers. Marketing is not included in the standard publishing package, and any extensive marketing campaigns (e.g., paid advertising, and book launch events) often require additional fees.
In contrast, Scribe Media provides a more comprehensive suite of marketing services as part of their publishing packages. These services include strategic marketing plans, social media support, and targeted advertising campaigns aimed at increasing book visibility. They also offer distribution to major platforms such as Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and Apple Books, and will help authors create a professional author platform, including social media branding and website development. For higher-tier packages, Scribe even assists with PR outreach and securing media coverage. However, these marketing services are included only in the higher-tier publishing packages, such as the Scribe Professional and Guided Author plans, which come at a significant cost (up to $56,000). For the most comprehensive marketing services, authors may need to purchase additional options beyond the base publishing package.
In terms of ease, Scribe Media makes marketing more accessible by integrating it into their higher-end publishing packages, saving authors the hassle of coordinating multiple service providers. The services are extensive but also come with a high price tag, so they might not be suitable for authors on a tight budget.
Key Takeaways:
- Simon & Schuster provides basic marketing support, but much of the work is up to the author, especially for first-time or less well-known writers. Marketing is not included in the base publishing package.
- Scribe Media offers comprehensive marketing services as part of their publishing packages, but these services are available only in their higher-tier plans, which can be quite expensive. They are more proactive in helping authors build their presence and reach a wider audience.
In conclusion, if you’re looking for hands-on, all-inclusive marketing support, Scribe Media provides a more robust offering compared to Simon & Schuster, but at a higher cost. For authors who are willing to do more of the legwork or who have the budget for additional marketing services, Simon & Schuster might be a more affordable starting point.
POD & Distribution: Simon & Schuster vs. Scribe Media
Distribution and Print-on-Demand (POD) services are critical components of the publishing process, and both Simon & Schuster and Scribe Media offer different approaches when it comes to getting books into the hands of readers. However, their services vary significantly in scope, and understanding how each company handles distribution and POD can help authors decide which option best fits their needs.
Simon & Schuster’s Distribution & POD
Simon & Schuster provides wide distribution through traditional retail channels. Their network includes major online retailers (Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Apple Books, etc.), physical bookstores, and libraries, making it an excellent choice for authors looking for broad visibility. However, this level of distribution is generally available to authors who sign with the company through a traditional publishing deal, which typically requires an agent. Self-publishing authors seeking a more straightforward publishing option with Simon & Schuster may not find the same access to retail distribution unless they sign a specific agreement.
Simon & Schuster does not primarily focus on Print-on-Demand (POD), as their model is geared towards large-scale print runs, often requiring authors to meet minimum order quantities. Authors can still benefit from the retail distribution of physical books, but traditional print runs may involve upfront costs and inventory management, unlike a more flexible POD service.
For self-publishing authors who are looking for distribution options without the commitment of a traditional publishing deal, Simon & Schuster may not be the best fit unless the author is looking for a hybrid model with a significant print run. Distribution is not typically included in the initial fee with Simon & Schuster and is rather part of a traditional publishing deal that often requires author representation (via an agent).
Scribe Media’s Distribution & POD
Scribe Media, on the other hand, is a self-publishing platform that provides authors with Print-on-Demand (POD) options. Their distribution process is more flexible and geared toward independent authors looking to retain control over their books. Scribe Media offers access to global distribution networks, including Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Apple Books, and other major platforms, similar to Simon & Schuster. Additionally, Scribe Media also utilizes IngramSpark, a key POD and global distribution partner, to ensure that books are available to international markets, independent bookstores, and libraries.
The key difference with Scribe Media is that their POD services allow authors to avoid large upfront print runs. Instead, books are printed only when orders are placed, making it a more cost-effective solution for authors who want to publish without worrying about inventory. This also means that authors don’t need to make large financial investments upfront, reducing the financial risk associated with printing excess copies. POD also allows for more flexibility in pricing, as authors can adjust the price of their book according to demand and market trends.
The distribution service is included in Scribe’s publishing packages, including the Scribe Publishing, Guided Author, and Scribe Professional plans. This allows authors to distribute their books to key retailers without incurring additional charges. The extensive distribution networks help ensure that books have a broad reach, making Scribe Media an attractive option for authors looking for both POD and wide distribution.
Key Takeaways:
- Simon & Schuster focuses on traditional distribution through retail and bookstores, offering a broad reach, but its service is not centered on POD. It may involve upfront costs for inventory, making it less flexible than a POD-based model.
- Scribe Media, on the other hand, provides POD and broad global distribution, making it more suitable for self-published authors who want to print books on demand and reach major retailers and international markets without the upfront investment.
In conclusion, if you’re looking for flexibility and cost-effective distribution without upfront printing costs, Scribe Media excels with its Print-on-Demand services and global distribution networks. However, if you’re looking for a traditional, large-scale distribution through retailers and bookstores, and are willing to commit to a larger print run, Simon & Schuster offers solid distribution options as part of its traditional publishing model, though it does not emphasize POD.
Support Services: Simon & Schuster vs. Scribe Media
Support is a critical factor for authors navigating the complex world of publishing, and both Simon & Schuster and Scribe Media provide different levels of assistance. The type and extent of support available can significantly impact an author’s experience throughout the publishing process.
Simon & Schuster’s Author Support
Simon & Schuster operates primarily through a traditional publishing model, which means they offer full-service support to authors who secure a publishing deal. Once an author is accepted, they are provided with a dedicated editor, and often, a marketing team to help with book promotion. However, Simon & Schuster is selective about the authors they publish, and self-published authors looking to work with them typically need to go through the submission process, which may involve working with a literary agent.
For self-published authors, Simon & Schuster does not provide a direct support structure like a publishing manager or hands-on guidance. Their model revolves more around traditional publishing relationships after a deal is struck. While Simon & Schuster’s support structure is robust for traditionally published authors, it may not be as comprehensive for those looking for more personalized assistance through self-publishing routes.
Scribe Media’s Author Support
In contrast, Scribe Media offers a high-touch support system tailored to self-published authors. Every author who chooses to publish with Scribe is assigned a dedicated publishing manager who oversees the entire process. This includes helping with the writing, editing, design, and marketing stages, ensuring that authors are supported every step of the way.
Scribe’s model is built around providing personalized, hands-on assistance, making it a more supportive environment for authors who may be new to the publishing world or who need guidance throughout the process. Authors also receive direct access to Scribe’s expert team, which includes professional editors, designers, and marketers. This level of support helps ensure that authors are never left on their own to figure things out. Additionally, Scribe’s dedicated publishing manager serves as a single point of contact, streamlining communication and making the process easier to navigate.
Key Takeaways:
- Simon & Schuster offers strong support for traditionally published authors, with dedicated teams such as editors and marketers. However, self-published authors are less likely to receive personal guidance unless they secure a traditional publishing deal.
- Scribe Media provides high-touch, personalized support for self-published authors, including a dedicated publishing manager throughout the entire publishing process. This makes it ideal for authors who prefer comprehensive, hands-on assistance.
In summary, Scribe Media excels in personalized support, offering more direct and consistent guidance, while Simon & Schuster offers strong support but mainly for authors who are signed to traditional contracts.
Customer Experience and Reviews: Simon & Schuster vs. Scribe Media
Simon & Schuster is a well-established name in traditional publishing, offering a professional experience for authors who secure a deal. Authors appreciate the access to expert teams and the prestige of being published by a major house. However, the selective submission process and long wait times can be frustrating, especially for new or self-published authors. While reviews are generally positive for those with a deal, aspiring authors may find the process challenging.
- Ratings: Positive for published authors, more mixed for those seeking a deal.
- Google/Trustpilot: Strong ratings from traditionally published authors; more neutral for self-published authors.
Scribe Media, on the other hand, is known for its premium self-publishing services, offering personalized support from a dedicated manager. Authors appreciate the high-quality work and hands-on guidance throughout the publishing process. However, the high cost of services is a common concern. Despite this, Scribe has a strong reputation for delivering professional, polished books and comprehensive support.
- Ratings: Generally positive, with 5-star reviews for quality and customer support.
- Google/Trustpilot: High ratings for the overall experience, though pricing can be a barrier for some.
In summary, Simon & Schuster excels in traditional publishing, while Scribe Media is ideal for authors seeking a premium self-publishing experience with top-tier support, but at a higher cost.
Simon & Schuster vs Scribe Media Which is Right for you
When deciding between Simon & Schuster and Scribe Media, the best choice for you largely depends on your goals, budget, and the type of publishing experience you’re seeking.
If you’re a first-time author, Simon & Schuster could be an excellent option if you’re looking for the traditional publishing route. As one of the top publishing houses, Simon & Schuster offers prestige, global reach, and the opportunity to be backed by a major publisher. However, it’s a competitive process, and you’ll need to secure a literary agent and face long timelines to see your book published. For those seeking a self-publishing model, Scribe Media offers more accessible support, though it comes at a premium cost. While Simon & Schuster may be better suited for authors aiming for a traditional, agent-backed deal, Scribe is ideal for those who want personalized guidance through the self-publishing process.
When it comes to marketing services, Scribe Media stands out. It offers comprehensive, personalized marketing strategies, including social media promotion, book campaigns, and professional consultations. These services are designed to make marketing less daunting for authors. On the other hand, while Simon & Schuster does provide marketing efforts, these are generally limited to more high-profile books and major releases. If marketing is a top priority for you, Scribe Media’s specialized services will give you a more hands-on approach.
Finally, if you’re an entrepreneur, thought leader, or professional seeking to self-publish with a premium service, Scribe Media is likely your best bet. It offers a comprehensive package with writing, editing, and marketing services, making it a great choice for authors looking to publish polished, professional non-fiction books. However, if you’re aiming for a traditional route with the chance of getting noticed by a major publishing house, then Simon & Schuster is the way to go.
Ultimately, both companies have their strengths, but the right choice depends on your publishing needs, whether that’s a traditional publishing deal or a premium self-publishing experience. For more detailed information, visit their respective websites.
For more in-depth looks at Simon & Schuster and Scribe Media check out our reviews for each of them right here on Top10! For more specific details, visit their respective websites to explore services and pricing tailored to your needs.